Denver judge cites ICE officials for re-detaining released immigrants
Judge Charlotte Sweeney found that officials violated court orders in Aurora, warning that future violations could trigger fines or other penalties.
By Madison Darwish ·

U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte Sweeney issued a contempt ruling on Wednesday against top Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials for repeatedly re-detaining immigrants after judicial orders mandated their release. The 15-page decision serves as a formal warning to Colorado ICE and Department of Homeland Security leadership to comply with court orders. Sweeney stated that the agency’s practice of immediately re-detaining petitioners made a mockery of judicial mandates.
The ruling follows a six-week period in which at least 18 individuals in Colorado were held longer than required or re-arrested shortly after release. Immigration attorneys believe the actual number is higher because it includes self-represented immigrants. Sweeney described the agency's behavior as stuns and renders a listener speechless, citing the Supreme Court's historical view that the United States is a government of laws and not of men.
The contempt finding stems from the case of Ramon Quintero Alvarez, a Mexican-born resident who entered the U.S. between 1993 and 1994. Alvarez has lived in Wyoming for 12 years with his two American-born sons. During an October hearing for a writ of habeas corpus, the federal government failed to show cause for keeping him in detention by October 27. After his release from immigration custody, Alvarez was immediately re-detained after taking a few steps into freedom.
Sweeney determined this re-detention was unlawful. The judge noted that ICE officials provided conflicting testimony regarding their authority during recent hearings. Nichole Black, the assistant field office director for ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations, stated under oath that she received a direct order from a supervisor to re-detain immigrants who had some type of criminality. Black admitted she believed it was permissible to escort someone to a public area and immediately re-detain them despite a contrary court order.
Black’s supervisor, Nathan Rasper, told Sweeney that he felt obligated to make lawful arrests and believed he could re-arrest people based on a policy in Minnesota. Rasper testified that he had since stopped re-arresting people who were ordered released from detention. Sweeney credited this change in behavior for sparing the federal government greater consequences. She wrote that because the government cured the contempt by ceasing the practice, the court declined to impose fines or order further behavioral changes.
The ruling marks a rare instance of a federal judge exercising broad contempt powers against executive branch officials in the immigration context. Sweeney’s decision was laced with references to the Constitution and decades of case law. She emphasized that the system of jurisprudence rests on the assumption that all individuals, whatever their position in government, are subject to federal law. No man is above the law, she wrote, citing a 1979 case.
U.S. Attorney Peter McNeilly, who leads the Colorado U.S. Attorney’s Office, had no comment on Wednesday regarding the order. McNeilly attended at least one of the recent hearings as a spectator. The next step in the process involves monitoring compliance with existing orders, with Sweeney indicating she would not hesitate to revisit the matter if violations occur again.






