Knesset legal adviser directs transfer of attorney-general bill to separate committee
Legal adviser Sagit Afik ruled that MK Gilad Kariv should not chair discussions on repealing the attorney-general law due to a potential conflict of interest.
By Madison Darwish ·

Sagit Afik, the legal adviser to the Knesset, issued a directive on Sunday requiring that deliberations on a specific bill be moved to a different legislative committee. The bill in question seeks to repeal legislation enacted by the outgoing coalition of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, which significantly reduced the authority of the attorney-general. Afik determined that MK Gilad Kariv, a member of the Democratic party, should not chair these specific discussions due to concerns regarding a conflict of interest.
This decision follows Kariv's recent appointment as the chair of the new Knesset committee tasked with leading efforts to dismantle key components of the judicial overhaul passed by Netanyahu's government. The legal adviser's intervention was prompted by the need to ensure procedural fairness while the committee addresses these major legislative changes.
The underlying conflict of interest stems from an active investigation into Kariv. Reports indicate that this case has been referred to Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara, who is currently weighing a decision on its final outcome. The investigation centers on allegations that Kariv leaked classified information during a meeting of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee held in June 2023. That session included a security briefing delivered by Prime Minister Netanyahu.
Prior to receiving the formal directive from Afik, Kariv had proactively sent a letter to the legal adviser. In his communication, he stated that he would refrain from chairing the committee's deliberations on the bill weakening the attorney-general's role. He cited the desire to prevent any appearance of impropriety regarding the potential conflict of interest. Kariv indicated that he intended to continue chairing discussions on the other bills within his committee's purview.
Afik responded to Kariv's letter by affirming that the conflict-of-interest concerns justified moving the deliberations on the attorney-general repeal law to another committee that Kariv does not chair. She noted that this structural change would help reduce the concern regarding the possibility of improper pressure being exerted during the legislative process.
Despite the transfer of the chairing role for this specific bill, Afik clarified that Kariv would not be excluded from the process entirely. He remains permitted to participate in the discussions held by the other committee and will retain the right to vote on the bill.
The ruling highlights the delicate balance required in the current legislative environment, where members of the new Knesset are tasked with reversing significant legal frameworks established by their predecessors. The involvement of the legal adviser underscores the importance of navigating potential conflicts of interest, particularly when the subject matter involves the very office investigating the committee chair.
The decision ensures that the process of repealing the judicial overhaul components continues while addressing procedural concerns. It allows the legislative work to proceed without halting progress on the other bills, maintaining momentum in the new Knesset's agenda.
By transferring the chairing duties for this particular bill, the Knesset legal adviser aims to safeguard the integrity of the debate. This approach allows for a more neutral environment in which the bill can be scrutinized and voted upon.
The situation serves as a notable example of how internal investigations can influence legislative procedures in the Israeli parliament. As the new committee moves forward with its broader mandate, the handling of this specific bill will likely be watched closely by legal experts and political observers alike.






