AdvertiseDonate
True Media Live · 685 Citadel Drive East, Colorado Springs, CO 80909

Home Secretary Calls for Probe into Birmingham Supported Housing Sector

Shabana Mahmood has urged an independent investigation into the supported exempt accommodation system after a review revealed over £615m in payments without sufficient evidence of care.

By Alina Marshall ·

Illustration for: Home Secretary Calls for Probe into Birmingham Supported Housing Sector
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has initiated a call for an independent investigation into the supported exempt accommodation sector in Birmingham. Speaking on the challenges facing her constituency, she stated that she smells a rat regarding the management of housing for vulnerable residents. This move follows growing concerns about escalating costs and the potential for exploitation within the system.

The supported exempt accommodation framework is intended to assist individuals with complex needs, including those dealing with addiction, women escaping domestic abuse, and former prisoners. The scheme provides these residents with housing alongside care, support, and supervision. However, a coalition of politicians, charities, and local residents has raised alarms about the presence of rogue providers. They argue that some operators fail to deliver the promised support, exposing residents to exploitation and antisocial behaviour.

An internal examination conducted by Birmingham city council highlighted the scale of the financial outlay. The review found that more than £615 million in housing benefit was paid out over a 15 month period. Crucially, this spending occurred without timely evidence that the relevant support services were actually being provided to the residents living in these properties.

Mahmood, the MP for Birmingham Ladywood, described the local situation as an outlier compared to the rest of the country. She told the Birmingham Mail that the abuse of the system is causing significant issues in her communities. The home secretary noted that she is in discussions with Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, regarding the enhanced housing benefits that fund this sector.

The volume of people living in supported exempt accommodation in Birmingham is striking. The city is home to more than 34,000 residents across approximately 12,200 properties. This figure far exceeds the 22,000 residents in London, despite the capital having a population seven times larger than Birmingham. While some attribute this concentration to higher local demand, others criticize both the local council and the national government for regulatory failures.

The independent review, commissioned by the council’s cross party audit committee, assessed the local authority’s approach to the sector. It concluded that the current methods are not fully effective, noting that risks are not always managed properly. The report identified that 12,700 live cases were awaiting review to verify that care and supervision were in place after tenancies began. Consequently, the council continued to release enhanced housing benefit payments without timely proof of support.

Further scrutiny of the data revealed that some housing benefit claims had remained active for over a decade, with some exceeding 20 years, without undergoing eligibility checks. Marcus Bernasconi, a Labour councillor, supported the push for an independent investigation. He stated that the council had lost control of the situation, with the taxpayer bill reaching hundreds of millions of pounds while the quality of support remained uncertain.

Although government legislation to strengthen regulation, including a new licensing scheme, was passed in 2023, it remains under consultation. A spokesperson for Birmingham city council said the review provides assurance that their assessment processes are robust and include controls beyond those of other councils. However, the spokesperson acknowledged that the sector still lacks adequate regulation for the council to effectively manage it.

A government spokesperson added that they have been closely monitoring the issues in Birmingham. They are actively considering next steps to ensure that supported housing in the city meets high quality standards. The aim is to prevent poor providers from taking advantage of a system designed to help the most vulnerable, while also taking broader action to raise standards across the sector.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get True Media Live in your inboxBig-city news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get True Media Live in your inboxBig-city news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.