Eisenkot's Coalition Talks Stalled as Rivals Seek Different Paths to Power
Gadi Eisenkot's change bloc controls the Knesset but faces internal divisions over whether to form a unity government, a haredi-backed cabinet, or a minority coalition.
By Emmanuel Faure ·

Gadi Eisenkot’s change bloc has demonstrated its ability to control the Israeli parliament, but significant internal disagreements are hindering efforts to form a stable government. On Tuesday, the bloc secured enough votes to appoint Matan Kahana as the Knesset speaker, effectively seizing legislative control from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s camp. This development places Israel in a divided state where the executive branch remains with the pro-Netanyahu faction while the legislature is led by the opposition. The change bloc is already using this leverage to reverse several institutional reforms, including specific judicial and media regulation bills passed by the caretaker government.
The coalition negotiations, now entering their third week, remain stuck due to conflicting priorities among the four parties in the change bloc. These parties are Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar, Naftali Bennett’s B’Yachad, Yair Golan’s Democrats, and Avigdor Liberman’s Yisrael Beytenu. Each leader is advocating for a different composition of the next government, creating a complex diplomatic challenge. Bennett has signaled a strong preference for a unity government that includes the Likud party, meeting with Netanyahu for over two hours on Wednesday to discuss the possibility. Such a government would combine Likud, Yashar, B’Yachad, and Yisrael Beytenu, resulting in a solid majority of 67 seats.
A unity government would exclude haredi and Arab parties, as well as ideological extremes, potentially allowing for progress on long-standing issues like haredi conscription and the balance of power between judicial and legislative branches. However, Liberman has expressed a strong reluctance to serve in a cabinet with Netanyahu. If Liberman’s party is excluded, the Religious Zionist party could fill the gap, resulting in a 64-seat government with a slightly more right-wing orientation. Key unresolved issues include the order of prime ministerial rotation, with Bennett’s associates insisting that Eisenkot must serve first if a unity deal is reached.
Liberman prefers a narrower government supported by the haredi parties. This option would involve the 48 seats of the change bloc plus 13 from the United Torah Judaism and Shas parties, totaling 61 seats. This configuration would likely require shelving major expansions of haredi conscription, as the haredi parties would demand protection for yeshiva student exemptions. Liberman, who recently took over temporary leadership of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, noted that any conscription bill must also satisfy the spiritual leader of United Torah Judaism, a condition that limits the scope of potential reform.
A third option, favored by Yair Golan, involves seeking support from the Arab parties. Golan urges Eisenkot to bring Mansour Abbas’s Ra’am party into the coalition, creating a 56-seat bloc against Netanyahu’s 53. The Joint List could then support the government from outside the coalition. While Bennett and Liberman oppose this approach, citing concerns about civic unrest, Eisenkot remains open to it if it ensures Netanyahu’s departure. Former labor minister Haim Ramon has proposed a variation where Eisenkot forms a 48-seat minority government first and addresses broader coalition dynamics after taking office.
Ramon suggests that Eisenkot present a minority cabinet to the Knesset, daring Bennett and Liberman to block it if they wish to keep Netanyahu in power. This strategy would force a high-stakes vote where the Arab parties’ abstention or support would determine the outcome. Currently, the political landscape is defined by competing desires: Bennett wants unity, Liberman wants a haredi deal, Golan wants Arab support, and Eisenkot wants Netanyahu out by any means necessary. Netanyahu, meanwhile, aims to maintain his position while his rivals negotiate. Until these factions find common ground, Israel will continue to lack a stable and workable government.






