Tim Hortons App Data Practices: Israeli Links and Privacy Gaps
A report reveals that the coffee chain’s app transmits user data to Forter, a firm whose founders come from an Israeli military unit.
By Emmanuel Faure ·

Canadians using the Tim Hortons app for their morning coffee may also be exporting their digital fingerprints to an Israeli cybertech firm.
On Tuesday, the advocacy group Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CPJME) confirmed that the app sends sensitive user data to Forter. Al Jazeera independently verified this data-sharing arrangement. The discovery follows an investigation by broadcaster CBC, which examined popular Canadian apps but did not identify the specific third-party recipient or its location.
The timeline of this controversy spans several years. In 2022, federal and provincial privacy commissioners found that Tim Hortons illegally tracked users’ locations through a third-party provider, even when the app was closed. The company faced no fines because Canada’s privacy regulator lacked the power to impose them. This year, in June, the government introduced Bill C-36, a new privacy bill that would introduce financial penalties and require privacy impact assessments before data leaves the country.
Experts question whether the data collection is proportionate to the act of buying coffee. Joel Reardon, a computer science professor at the University of Calgary, noted that the collection occurs before user consent and is excessive. He explained that Forter gathers unique identifiers, sensor details, and nearby Wi-Fi network names to create a device fingerprint. This allows the firm to identify users in the future. Reardon stated that effective fraud prevention does not require precise ongoing location data.
The connection to Forter raises specific concerns for CPJME. The group’s director of media advocacy, Jason Toney, pointed out that Forter’s founders are alumni of Unit 8200, the Israeli military’s signals intelligence division. That unit is linked to Lavender, an AI system used to generate targeting lists during the war in Gaza. Toney cautioned against speculating on how the data is used but emphasized that the digital footprint is built seemingly without user knowledge. He noted that Forter has publicly framed its work as protecting wealthy corporations from fraud costs rather than safeguarding ordinary consumers.
Matt Hatfield, executive director of the digital rights group OpenMedia, said Tim Hortons is not unusual in passing data to long chains of vendors. However, he argued that Canada’s privacy laws are outdated. The current law, PIPEDA, is over 25 years old and allows companies to share data with service providers without explicit consent, provided the company remains accountable. Hatfield warned that under the proposed Bill C-36, a new regulator must consider trade agreements and economic growth before investigating privacy violations. This could allow the government to pressure the regulator to ignore violations involving close trade partners.
Tim Hortons told CBC that the data-sharing arrangement is a fraud-prevention measure and that it does not sell users’ personal information. Neither Tim Hortons, its parent company Restaurant Brands International, nor Forter responded to Al Jazeera’s queries by publication time. Al Jazeera could not confirm whether Forter still uses Israeli military intelligence or if the data is accessible to Israeli government agencies.
CPJME has called for a new inquiry by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada into Tim Hortons’ data handling. The group also filed a complaint with the CBC ombudsperson, arguing that the broadcaster failed to disclose Forter’s identity. Johanna Gunawan, an assistant professor of computer science and law at Maastricht University, stated that consumers are often unaware of the particulars in privacy policies. She argued that companies must take responsibility for the practices of their third-party providers, ensuring transparency and due diligence.






