AdvertiseDonate
True Media Live · 685 Citadel Drive East, Colorado Springs, CO 80909

Federal Judge Criticizes LSU Legal Team Over 'Hallucinated' Citation Claim

A federal judge in Alabama demanded retraction and public apologies from LSU lawyers who accused the SEC of hallucinating legal citations in a court filing.

By Alina Marshall ·

Illustration for: Federal Judge Criticizes LSU Legal Team Over 'Hallucinated' Citation Claim
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A federal judge in Birmingham, Alabama, scolded attorneys representing Louisiana State University on Wednesday after they claimed the Southeastern Conference hallucinated citations in a legal filing. Judge Annemarie Carney Axon required a retraction of the language and asked for heartfelt public statements expressing regret for the remarks, which she felt maligned the character of the opposing counsel.

The dispute stems from a lawsuit the SEC filed against LSU in September regarding the university's efforts to play professional athletes. Although the LSU football team did not ultimately roster the former pros it sought to sign, the legal battle has continued to advance through the court system. The timing of the hearing is notable, as the LSU basketball team rostered former professional RJ Luis on Tuesday following a local judge's ruling that confirmed his eligibility.

The Wednesday hearing at the Hugo L. Black United States Courthouse focused on specific language in an LSU filing. That document accused the SEC of negligently supplying or hallucinating case citations. In response, the SEC described the statement as scandalous and professionally insulting.

Judge Axon questioned LSU attorney Bruce Rogers extensively regarding the choice of the word hallucinated. She clarified with Rogers that the citations in question were indeed legitimate. Rogers acknowledged that they were not made-up cases but argued that the term was appropriate because the holdings of those cases did not support the SEC's argument.

Axon pushed back on this interpretation, asking Rogers if he did not understand the ramifications of alleging that someone hallucinated something. Rogers maintained that the brief was not calling out the lawyers directly, a claim Axon said was the opposite of what was written in the document. Rogers noted that the brief had been written by the solicitor general of the state of Louisiana, and Axon confirmed there was sufficient time for him to attend the proceeding.

Rogers argued that the term hallucinated was a broader concept drawn from artificial intelligence terminology, where models distort facts. He pointed out that the SEC's filing mentioned the use of AI but also stated that the document was independently reviewed before submission. When asked if she considered attacks on professional reputation to be legitimate advocacy, Axon asked Rogers directly, to which he replied in the negative.

Axon emphasized that Rogers would not want to be wrongly accused of hallucinating a case while fully understanding the implication. She told Rogers that they were not dressing up the issue and that there was no time to put lipstick on the pig. Rogers agreed with the judge that it was not appropriate to attack the character of another member of the bar.

SEC attorney Tom Warburton briefly addressed the court, noting that one of their major fears was that the language would be picked up in public media. He presented multiple instances of this occurring, including a printout from USA Today. Rogers stated that LSU would file a request in the afternoon to remove the term hallucinated from the filing.

Judge Axon instructed Rogers to file the motion and to include that the language exhibited poor professional judgment. She added that heartfelt and robust public statements from Rogers, LSU, and the attorney general's office would need to be approved by her. Closing the proceeding, Axon told Rogers it had been a privilege to work with him before her time on the bench but expressed her disappointment. She warned that if such an occurrence happens again, he would be sanctioned to the fullest extent possible.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get True Media Live in your inboxBig-city news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get True Media Live in your inboxBig-city news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.