Justice Department vows to keep probing noncitizen voting after dropping California lawsuit
Federal officials plan to pursue criminal charges and maintain subpoenas in several counties despite recent court losses.
By Emmanuel Faure ·

The U.S. Department of Justice announced on Thursday that it will continue its criminal and civil investigations into alleged noncitizen voting. Attorney General Todd Blanche stated that the department’s work on election integrity will not pause following the recent election results. This commitment comes as the federal government maintains active cases in multiple states despite a series of unfavorable court rulings.
In mid-October, federal officials alleged that 20,000 likely noncitizens were registered in California. The Justice Department sued the state to force officials to exclude ballots from unverified voters. A federal judge and an appeals court rejected those requests, and the Supreme Court declined to intervene. The Justice Department dropped its lawsuit last week but has not withdrawn grand jury subpoenas sent to several California counties in the days before Election Day.
Anna Baldwin, director of voting rights litigation at Campaign Legal Center, noted that the administration faces substantial roadblocks. She argued that the program lacks congressional authorization and that recent court orders reaffirmed state authority over election administration. One D.C. federal judge ruled that the Justice Department and Homeland Security lack statutory authority to distribute noncitizen lists to election officials. Another judge vacated the department’s project to request unredacted voter rolls, finding the actions unlawful.
Local prosecutors are also moving forward. San Luis Obispo District Attorney Dan Dow is investigating 63 individuals flagged by federal officials in his county. He has charged one person so far. James Williams, county executive for Santa Clara County, said his office is prepared to deal with the ongoing pressure. He described the federal drive as an attempt to conjure facts that do not exist.
Data experts have questioned the accuracy of the federal lists. A University of California Los Angeles analysis of the 20,000-name list found that 42% of those names did not appear on California’s current voter roll. The study also identified naturalized citizens on the list. Santa Cruz County election official Tricia Webber reported that more than half of the 81 names sent to her county were not registered locally, and some dates of birth were in the future.
The Justice Department says it will continue to enforce federal election laws based on facts and the law. Subpoenas sent to Los Angeles, Sonoma, and Santa Clara counties request records on how local officials responded to federal demands to segregate ballots. With Democrats controlling Congress, lawmakers may hold hearings to scrutinize the methodology used by federal agencies to compile these lists.






