Five EU Nations Advance Plan to Send Rejected Asylum Seekers to Rwanda
Germany, Denmark, Austria, Greece and the Netherlands have agreed in principle with Rwanda to open a return hub in 2027 for migrants under deportation orders, though legal and logistical questions remain unresolved.
By Alina Marshall ·

Five European Union countries have agreed in principle with Rwanda to establish a deportation facility in the landlocked African nation, where they hope to send migrants whose asylum claims have been rejected. Germany, Denmark, Austria, Greece and the Netherlands plan to open the so-called return hub in 2027.
The proposal echoes President Trump's policy of deporting migrants to third countries with which they have no links, as well as an earlier British government effort that collapsed in the courts. It reflects an attempt by the five nations to respond to widespread public concern over mass migration, which has driven political change across the continent, but the plan is far from certain to succeed or even to begin.
Unlike the American program, the European arrangement would cover only migrants who have exhausted every legal avenue to remain in Europe and have been placed under a deportation order. Instead of being sent back to their countries of origin, some would be transferred to Rwanda and given the choice of staying there or returning home. The hub is meant to offer an alternative when deportation to a home country is impossible, either because that country refuses to accept its nationals or because return could put the migrant in danger.
European governments face mounting pressure from voters to reduce migration. In Germany, for instance, there were some 230,000 foreign nationals legally required to leave at the end of 2025, according to the Die Welt newspaper, yet government figures show fewer than 23,000 deportations were carried out during the year.
"If people without the right to remain in the EU cannot be removed from the country, our entire asylum system becomes absurd," Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said this week. "If the state sets limits, then these must be respected." Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen called the announcement "a crucial step toward a new migration system," while Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said Rwanda would provide "a second chance to people who no longer have the legal right to remain in the partner countries." According to a Dutch government statement, deportees would first be housed in an "open, temporary facility" and, if they stayed, would have access to education, the labor market, healthcare and the legal system.
Significant legal and logistical hurdles remain. Dr. Peter W. Walsh, a senior researcher at the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford, told CBS News the countries must still negotiate with Rwanda over eligibility, the legal status and rights of transferees, how facilities would run, funding, and monitoring of treatment after transfer. "A big open question is what Rwanda will receive as part of the deal, such as financial payments, as was the case with the U.K.-Rwanda agreement," he said. Britain's Supreme Court ruled the earlier British plan illegal over concerns that people sent to Rwanda could be passed on to countries where they faced persecution or serious harm, and the Labour government scrapped that policy completely in July 2024.
Walsh noted key differences from the British scheme, under which asylum seekers would have had their claims decided in Rwanda, whereas the European plan targets people already found to have no right to remain. "This distinction may avoid some of the specific legal problems that affected the U.K. scheme," he said, adding that EU rules explicitly allowing member states to establish return hubs outside the bloc provide a clearer legal framework. Still, he cautioned, "this does not mean that transfers to Rwanda would automatically be lawful," and said the agreement alone would not settle questions of safety and individual rights.
Humanitarian groups have criticized the proposal on both legal and practical grounds. The Danish Refugee Council told CBS News it was "deeply concerned and disappointed," with EU director Céline Mias saying, "Instead of fixing existing EU asylum and return systems, Member States are creating a costly new mechanism and calling it innovative." The council said its research shows restrictive migration policies fail to deter people while carrying severe consequences for human lives. Amnesty International warned the deal could "become a cruel black hole for human rights," citing Rwanda's long criticized rights record.
The participating governments say the hub will be developed in line with EU and international law, including human rights obligations, and that national agencies are already coordinating with the European Commission and international migration organizations. Walsh called the proposed timetable ambitious, saying a small pilot could conceivably begin in 2027 if transfers start with a limited group, but added that early transfers would not prove return hubs could substantially reduce overall departures from Europe. "And the question of scale will be key to the plan's hoped-for deterrent effect," he said.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






