Castle Rock resident Joseph Pagnotta dies at 74

Joseph Michael Pagnotta, a longtime Castle Rock resident and part owner of the clothing retailer Sheplers, died on Sunday, October 26, 2026. He was 74. His wife, Shari, and their three children were present at the time of his death.

Pagnotta was born on March 19, 1952, in Pueblo. He began his career working his way up to a position as a part owner at Sheplers. He described his motivation for the role as a desire to provide for his family and ensure they had opportunities in life. He also took pride in leadership and teaching others to succeed.

A former student-athlete at the University of Colorado, Pagnotta played football and track. He remained a lifelong sports fan, supporting the Colorado Buffaloes, the Denver Broncos, and the Denver Nuggets. He was particularly enthusiastic about his children's athletic achievements.

Pagnotta is survived by his wife, Shari; his children, Joeilyn Pagnotta, Ryan Pagnotta, and Matthew Pagnotta; and his grandchildren, Siena and Giovanni. His wife Ryan Pagnotta is married to Lauren, and his son Matthew Pagnotta is married to Laurel. He was preceded in death by his parents, Pete and Rose Pagnotta, and his brother, Anthony Pagnotta.

A memorial mass is scheduled for Wednesday, November 11, 2026, at 10:00 a.m. The service will take place at St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church in Castle Rock.